Hello dear
Welcome To Eaton Good
Eaton Good, located in Key West, FL, is a standout destination for BBQ enthusiasts and food lovers alike. This inviting eatery creates a warm, familial atmosphere that makes every patron feel at home. With a menu brimming with flavor, highlights include their delectable half chicken and succulent pulled pork, celebrated for their incredible quality and taste. Sides like roasted carrots, mac and cheese, and coleslaw further enhance the experience. Customers rave about the generous portions and friendly service, making each visit memorable. Whether you're craving a Cuban sandwich or exploring their diverse offerings, Eaton Good promises a satisfying and flavorful culinary journey.
Taste the best
Discover Our Menu
Water
US$3.60Jerk Chicken Caesar Wrap
US$14.501/4 Wood-Fired Rotisserie Jerk Chicken
US$18.00
1 Lb 16hr Smoked Pulled Pork
US$42.00Wings
US$12.001/2 Lb 16hr Smoked Pulled Pork
US$26.40
Cowboy Cookie
US$4.80A La Carte
US$28.80Whole Wood-Fired Rotisserie Jerk Chicken
US$42.00 About
Eaton Good
Welcome to Eaton Good, a culinary gem located at 1000 Eaton St, Key West, FL. This vibrant eatery has swiftly won the hearts—and stomachs—of locals and visitors alike, thanks to its authentic BBQ offerings and warm, family-friendly atmosphere.
From the moment you cross the threshold, you are greeted with the comforting aroma of smoked meats and the inviting vibe of a place that resembles a home away from home. Customers rave about the exceptional quality of the food and the earnest hospitality provided by the owners and staff. The reviews are overwhelmingly positive, with one delighted patron, Chris Morris, highlighting the incredible flavors of their half chicken and pulled pork, declaring them as the stars of the menu. The side dishes, including roasted carrots, further enhance the dining experience, proving that every element is crafted with love and care.
For those who can't decide, the advise from regulars is to embrace the entire menu, as one enthusiastic reviewer, Drielle Ion, suggests. The BBQ at Eaton Good is described as "real-deal," exuding authenticity that keeps guests coming back for more. The laid-back vibe makes it an ideal spot for friends and family to gather and indulge. It’s no wonder customers leave, not just satisfied, but already plotting their next visit.
Highlighted dishes include the delicious Cuban sandwich and the house special pulled pork. Ben Satterfield recalls his culinary delight upon tasting the half chicken and sides, drawing comparisons to home-cooked classics. Meanwhile, Anita Kostic's review praises the grilled cauliflower and the Italian sandwich, showcasing the menu's variety and capability to cater to diverse palates.
What truly sets Eaton Good apart is the warmth of the people behind it. Miguel Sanchez’s family left impressed not only by the food but also by the personal connection they formed with the owners. It's these interactions combined with exceptional cuisine that encapsulates the Eaton Good experience. Their BBQ sauces, bursting with flavor, are a must-try, and like profound conversations over dinner, they leave a lasting impression.
In summary, Eaton Good is more than just a restaurant; it’s a gathering place where great food and genuine hospitality intersect. Whether you're a BBQ aficionado or a curious first-timer, this establishment promises to deliver a delicious experience that you’ll want to revisit time and time again.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Split a half chicken, a half a pound of pulled pork, and four sides with a buddy. It was a ton of food and everything was excellent and full of flavor. Highlights for me were the chicken and roasted carrots. Amazing quality at a great value with top notch service. We saw other customers with sandwiches that looked phenomenal. Can’t wait to go back and try more menu items. ”
“ Couldn’t decide so we got it all. Highly advise you make the same call. If you’re craving real-deal BBQ with a laid-back, welcoming vibe, do yourself a favor and head to Eaton Good. It’s the kind of place that makes you feel like family the second you walk in the door. You’ll leave full, happy, and already planning your next visit! ”
“ Delicious 1/2 chicken, Cuban, Mac and cheese and potato salad - maybe better than Grandma’s. Other meats I was interested in - brisket and pork. Super nice staff and owners. Go here fast - ”
“ Food we tried was great! Cuban sandwich, Italian sandwich, pulled pork, coleslaw, grilled cauliflower with nice sauce . We were pleased with food and service. ”
“ Eaton Good is a gem, the food is amazing and the owners are incredible nice people. My family was blown away by the flavors here, everything from the bbq, pulled pork, the sauce we loved them all. After we dine, my 14 years old son spoke to the owners and told he’d be back because that was the best meat he’d ever had. Keep it up Eaton Good, we’ll be back in October. ”
“ My husband and I LOVE BBQ. We are so glad we found this place and it was absolutely delicious. The curry cauliflower is amazing. The chicken was fantastic. Definitely a most try when visiting Key West. ”
“ Hidden Gem! After arriving in Key West on the Key West Express we popped in for lunch and a beer. Hubby had the pulled pork sandwich and I had Jerk chicken with the carrots. Everything was excellent, don't let the habanero barbecue sauce scare you it has a slight 'bite', not hot and delicious. The carrots were like carrot fries that were the star in my opinion. A table next to us had the Max and Cheese that looked fantastic as well. ”
“ We found it difficult to find food in Key West that was high quality and flavorful, not just for drunk old tourists... but we LOVED Eaton Good! The people who run it are kind and amazing. The pulled pork was flavorful and juicy and the kale caesar was so good. ”